In the annals of India’s struggle for independence, numerous proposals and negotiations have shaped the course of history. One such pivotal moment was the introduction of the Rajagopalachari Formula, which held significant implications for India’s political landscape. For UPSC aspirants seeking a comprehensive understanding of India’s journey to independence and the intricate dynamics of its political evolution, delving into the intricacies of the Rajagopalachari Formula is imperative. This formula, put forth by C. Rajagopalachari, also known as Rajaji, emerged as a critical proposition during a crucial juncture in India’s post-independence trajectory.
Background
The Rajagopalachari Formula, also called the C. R. Formula or Rajaji Formula, was a suggestion made by C. Rajagopalachari to solve the disagreement between the All India Muslim League and the Indian National Congress about India’s independence from British rule. The League wanted a separate country for Muslims, but the Congress didn’t want India to be divided.
Points of C.R. Formula
- The Rajagopalachari Formula proposed that the Muslim League should agree to the Congress’s demand for independence.
- It suggested that both the Muslim League and the Congress cooperate in forming a provisional government at the center.
- After World War II, a vote would be held in Muslim-majority areas in North-West and North-East India to decide if they wanted a separate country.
- If partition was accepted, both parties would negotiate on how to manage defense, trade, and other important matters.
- However, these terms would only come into effect if Britain handed over full powers to India.
Reactions to the C.R. Formula
- The Rajagopalachari Formula was viewed as an implicit acknowledgment of the Muslim League’s call for Pakistan, and Mahatma Gandhi backed the suggestion.
- However, Muhammad Ali Jinnah insisted that the Congress openly embrace the two-nation theory, which advocated separate nations for Hindus and Muslims.
- Jinnah opposed the notion of the entire population participating in the plebiscite and preferred only Muslims in the Muslim-majority regions to have a voice.
- Hindu leaders, led by Vir Savarkar, criticized the CR plan too.
Why C.R. Formula Failed?
- The Rajagopalachari Formula seemed to agree with the idea of Pakistan, but it aimed to show that provinces claimed by Jinnah for Pakistan had many non-Muslim people living there. Jinnah said places like Punjab and Bengal were mostly Muslim. But if there was a vote, even non-Muslims would get to decide, which could split these places.
- Jinnah didn’t want to share a government with Congress. He mainly wanted a separate country for Muslims. Because the Rajagopalachari Formula didn’t match what Jinnah wanted for Pakistan, he said no to it.
- In summary, the Rajagopalachari Formula tried to find a compromise between Congress and the Muslim League about Pakistan. But because Jinnah didn’t agree, the plan failed, and India got divided into India and Pakistan in 1947.
In conclusion, the Rajagopalachari Formula represented a significant attempt to bridge the gap between the Indian National Congress and the Muslim League regarding the issue of Pakistan. It sought to find a middle ground by proposing cooperation between the two parties and advocating for a plebiscite in Muslim-majority areas to determine their political future. However, the formula faced staunch opposition from Muhammad Ali Jinnah, who insisted on the explicit acceptance of the two-nation theory and rejected the idea of a common center with Congress. His refusal to accept the proposal ultimately led to its failure.
Also Read: Quit India Movement