The Cabinet Mission, dispatched by the British government in 1946, marked a crucial turning point in India’s journey towards independence. This mission was tasked with devising a plan for transferring power from British rule to Indian hands, in response to the growing demands for self-governance and the tumultuous political landscape of the time. The arrival of the Cabinet Mission was met with great anticipation and hope among Indians, as it presented a tangible opportunity to negotiate the terms of independence. For many, it symbolized the beginning of the end of British colonial rule in India.
Background
The Cabinet Mission was a big step taken by the British government in February 1946 to find a peaceful way to give power back to India. The mission had three important members:
- Sir Stafford Cripps: He was part of the British government and had been involved in earlier missions to India during World War II.
- Lord Pethick-Lawrence: He was the main person in charge of the mission and was responsible for talking with Indian leaders.
- A.V. Alexander: He was also part of the mission and helped make decisions.
The main goal of the Cabinet Mission was to figure out how to give power to India and set up a stable government. They talked with different Indian political groups like the Congress, the Muslim League, and Hindu and Sikh leaders to agree on how India’s government would work.
- Clement Atlee, the British Prime Minister, wanted to find a peaceful way to give power back to India. He formed the Cabinet Mission to figure this out.
- The mission had three important members: Lord Pethick-Lawrence, AV Alexander, and Sir Stafford Cripps. Each one was really important for the mission.
- Even though Lord Wavell, the Viceroy of India, wasn’t part of the mission, he helped with the negotiations in India.
- The Congress and the Muslim League had different ideas about how India should be governed. Congress wanted a strong central government, while the Muslim League wanted to make sure Muslims had their rights protected.
- In May 1946, because Congress and the Muslim League couldn’t agree, the Cabinet Mission made its own suggestions. These included ideas about how India’s government should work, setting up an interim government, and creating a group to write India’s new constitution.
- Even though both Congress and the Muslim League agreed to the mission’s ideas at first, they couldn’t agree on everything. This led to the partition of India and the creation of Pakistan in August 1947.
- The Cabinet Mission couldn’t stop the partition, but its ideas and discussions were really important for giving power back to India and creating India and Pakistan.
Objective of Cabinet Mission
- The Cabinet Mission had a few main goals when it came to India:
- Agree on a Constitution for India: The mission wanted Indian leaders to agree on how India’s future constitution would look, which would help India become independent from British rule.
- Set up a Constitution-Making Group: They aimed to create a Constituent Assembly of India. This group would make the new constitution for India and have representatives from different provinces and princely states.
- Create an Interim Government with Support from Major Political Parties: The mission also wanted to set up a temporary government called the Executive Council. This government would include members from major Indian political parties and would work until the new constitution was ready.
- The Cabinet Mission came to Delhi in March 1946 and talked a lot with Indian leaders from different political parties. But because Congress and the Muslim League couldn’t agree on whether India should stay united or be split into parts, the mission made its own suggestions in May 1946.
- Their proposal didn’t agree to a separate Pakistan but suggested dividing provinces into Sections A, B, and C to make sure everyone had a say and some independence while still keeping India together.
- They also proposed a Constituent Assembly made up of members from different places and groups, with separate seats for different communities like Muslims and Sikhs. This assembly would write the constitution for provinces and, if possible, for the whole country.
- The mission wanted India to have a federal structure where provinces had a lot of power and princely states weren’t controlled by the British anymore.
- Their plan aimed to handle India’s diversity while showing a path to independence and future governance. But since Congress and the Muslim League couldn’t agree, India was eventually divided, and Pakistan was created.
Proposal from Cabinet Mission
- No Full-Fledged Pakistan: The proposal said no to a separate Pakistan because it would cause problems due to the large non-Muslim populations in the proposed areas. It also recognized that dividing the armed forces and other regions like western Bengal and parts of Punjab might be difficult.
- Dividing Provinces into Three Sections:
- Group A: Included states like Madras, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, and Bombay.
- Group B: Consisted of Punjab, Sindh, NWFP, and Baluchistan.
- Group C: Comprised Bengal and Assam.
- Three-Tiered Executive and Legislature: At provincial, section, and union levels, there would be three groups of leaders to make decisions and represent people.
- Proportional Representation in Constituent Assembly: Different groups like general, Muslims, and Sikhs would elect representatives to a Constituent Assembly that would write the constitution.
- Separate Representation for Groups A, B, and C: Members of each group would sit separately in the assembly to make decisions.
- Convening of the Constituent Assembly: The entire assembly, with representatives from all three groups, would meet to write the union constitution.
- Federal Structure: India would be organized in a federal way, with a central government controlling certain things like defense and foreign affairs.
- Communal Questions in Central Legislature: Decisions about religious issues in the central government would be made by a majority of both communities present.
- Provincial Autonomy and Princely States: Provinces would have a lot of power, and princely states would be free from British control to make their own decisions.
- Flexibility in Group Membership: Provinces could change their group after elections, and after ten years, they could ask to change the groups or the constitution.
Failure of Cabinet Mission
- Opposition to Grouping: Congress didn’t like the idea of dividing provinces based on Hindu-Muslim majorities and competing for power. They wanted a strong central government with provinces having their own powers, not competing groups.
- Muslim League’s Resistance: The Muslim League didn’t want to accept any changes to the proposals. They thought grouping was a step towards making Pakistan and didn’t want to agree to it.
- Rejection of Second Plan: When the first plan faced opposition, the mission suggested a second plan: dividing India into two parts – one for Hindus and one for Muslims (later named Pakistan). But Congress didn’t like this plan either.
- Communal Tensions: During this time, there were a lot of tensions between Hindus and Muslims. The Muslim League called for “Direct Action Day,” which led to a lot of riots and violence. This made the situation worse and stopped any chances of agreement.
- Inevitability of Partition: Because of the Cabinet Mission’s failure and the increasing violence, some Congress leaders, like Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, realized that dividing the country might be the only way to stop the violence and move forward.
The Cabinet Mission Plan was crucial in India’s early independence and constitution-making process. It continues to be studied by scholars, providing insights into the intricate historical and political factors that influenced India’s journey to independence.
Also Read: INA Trials