The Uniform Civil Code (UCC) has long been a subject of debate and discussion in Indian socio-political landscape. Its significance extends beyond mere legal discourse, touching upon the very fabric of Indian society and governance. As aspirants prepare for the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) examinations, understanding the importance of UCC becomes imperative. This article has all you need to know about Uniform Civil Code.
A Uniform Civil Code (UCC) entails equal treatment of all segments of society regardless of their religious affiliation under a national civil code applicable to all. It addresses various aspects such as marriage, divorce, maintenance, adoption, and property succession, grounded on principle of disconnecting religion from law in contemporary society.
Article 44 aligns with the Directive Principles of State Policy, advocating for the state’s efforts to establish a UCC across India’s territory.
India doesn’t have a Uniform Civil Code (UCC) applicable nationwide. Instead, various personal laws rooted in religious traditions regulate matters like marriage, divorce, inheritance, and adoption for different religious groups.
Despite this, both the central government and certain states have taken steps towards introducing a UCC. States including Goa and Uttarakhand has taken steps for implementation of UCC
States with UCC:
Goa was the pioneer state in India to adopt a Uniform Civil Code (UCC). Following its annexation in 1961, the Parliament enacted a law ensuring the continued application of the Portuguese Civil Code of 1867 in Goa. This code is applicable to all residents of Goa, irrespective of their religious or ethnic backgrounds.
Recently, Uttarakhand has also taken a significant step by passing the Uttarakhand Uniform Civil Code Bill 2024. It makes it the first state in India to implement UCC. This bill aims to establish a common law for various matters such as marriage, divorce, and inheritance of property, applying to all residents of Uttarakhand except Scheduled Tribes.
Historical Perspective for Uniform Civil Code:
Pre-Independence Era: The implementation of a uniform civil code in India traces its roots back to the colonial era. During this period, policymakers made efforts to bring about uniformity in certain aspects of Indian law, such as crimes and evidence. However, they kept personal laws governing different religious communities separate.
Post-Independence Era: Post-independence, leaders like Jawaharlal Nehru and Dr. B.R. Ambedkar advocated for a uniform civil code, but opposition from religious groups and limited awareness led to its inclusion in the Directive Principles of State Policy (Article 44). Significant reforms, including the enactment of the Hindu Code Bill, addressed issues like divorce and inheritance rights for daughters. Amendments to laws like the Hindu Succession Act furthered the cause of gender equality in inheritance rights.
Supreme Court Support to UCC
Arguments Supporting the Implementation of a Uniform Civil Code:
Celebrating Diversity, Strengthening Unity: Implementing UCC will promote national integration and secularism by removing distinctions based on religious personal laws. It will help in fostering a common identity among citizens, and facilitating inter-faith relationships.
Empowering Women through Uniformity: The UCC would ensure gender justice by eliminating discriminatory practices against women in personal laws, such as polygamy. Thus promoting equality and dignity for women.
Streamlining Laws for Legal Efficiency: India’s complex legal system burdened with overlapping personal laws leads to confusion and legal disputes. The UCC would simplify this framework, enhancing clarity, ease of implementation, and reducing the burden on the judiciary.
Integration of India: A UCC would integrate India further by bringing all citizens under a single national civil code, irrespective of caste, religion, or tribe.
Reducing Vote Bank Politics: Implementing a UCC could diminish vote bank politics prevalent during elections.
Eliminating Loopholes in Personal Laws: Personal laws create an alternate judicial system based on outdated values, and a UCC would rectify this.
Progressive Change: It’s essential to update laws to suit the present context rather than sticking to outdated practices.
Legal Mandate for Equality: Articles 14, 15, and 25 of the Indian Constitution uphold the principles of equality and non-discrimination, emphasizing the need for a UCC to align with these provisions.
Promoting genuine secularism: UCC doesn’t restrict anyone’s religious freedom. Instead, it ensures that everyone is treated equally under the law, regardless of their religious beliefs. In other words, all Indian citizens would be subject to the same laws, irrespective of their religion.
Ace how to write mains answers from here.
Argument against implementation Uniform Civil Code:
Diversification: Diversity of personal laws followed by various communities. Even within communities like Christians and Muslims, there isn’t complete uniformity in personal laws, making it difficult to achieve any kind of uniformity. Finding common ground among these diverse communities is a daunting task.
Custom Practices: The vast array of customary practices among different communities, including within Hindus. For instance, while Hindu marriages among relatives are discouraged in northern regions, they may be acceptable in other parts of the country. Bringing Hindus under a uniform law poses a primary hurdle to UCC implementation.
Imposing uniform laws may disregard the cultural practices and traditions of various religious groups, undermining diversity.
Constitution safeguard: Certain provisions of the Constitution safeguard the local customs of states like Nagaland, Meghalaya, and Mizoram, further complicating the implementation of UCC.
Wrong Perception: Many minorities fear that the UCC aims to Hinduize them, as its content hasn’t been clearly explained. This pose a major challenge in UCC implementation.
Undermining Federalism: Imposing a UCC might encroach upon states’ rights to legislate on personal matters, compromising the federal structure.
Way Forward:
India has diverse personal laws for Hindus, Muslims, Christians, Parsis, etc., but there’s no single family-related law acceptable to all religious communities. However, most agree that a Uniform Civil Code (UCC) would be beneficial for Indian unity. The debate lies in when and how to implement it.
The implementation of the Uniform Civil Code (UCC) is essential for fostering equality, justice, and national integration in India. Despite concerns from some communities about it being against their religion, UCC represents a modernization of religious laws and social progress. By eliminating discrimination based on religion, caste, and sex, the UCC ensures that all citizens are treated equally under the law, as mandated by Article 14 of the Indian Constitution. It will also streamline legal processes, leading to faster and fairer justice for all.
To effectively apply the UCC, the government should adopt piecemeal approaches, increase public awareness, and ensure that the code is balanced, unbiased, and respectful of religious sentiments. Ultimately, the UCC is a crucial step towards building a more progressive and unified nation.